Skip to main content
Home
Menu Close

Utility menu

  • Why join BASW
  • Events
  • Media Centre

Popular on BASW

Campaigning and influencing
World social work day
Social work stands against poverty
People with lived experience
Career stages
Cost of living crisis

Main navigation

  • About social work
    • What is social work?
    • Topics in social work
    • Professional Social Work (PSW) Magazine
  • Careers
    • Become a social worker
    • Returning to social work
    • For employers
    • Specialisms
    • Career stages
    • Jobs board
    • Work for BASW
  • About BASW
    • Campaigning and influencing
    • Governance
    • Social work around the UK
    • Awards
    • Social work conferences UK
    • International Work
    • Feedback, suggestions & complaints
  • Training & CPD
    • Professional Development
    • Professional Capabilities Framework
    • Let's Talk Social Work Podcast
  • Policy & Practice
    • Resources
    • National policies
    • Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion
    • Working with...
    • Research and knowledge
    • Standards
  • Support
    • Advice & representation
    • Social Workers Union (SWU)
    • Social Work Professional Support Service (SWPSS)
    • Independent social workers
    • Student Hub
    • Financial support
    • Groups and networks
    • Membership renewals
    • How to contact us
Professional Social Work Magazine

Professional Social Work Magazine (PSW)

Main navigation

  • Digital editions
  • Guidance for contributors
  • PSW articles
  • Advertising

What’s race got to do with it?

As a report shows Black children are 11 times more likely to be strip-searched by police than their white peers, Dr Arlene P. Weekes and Maureen Mguni take a social work and anti-racist look at the issue
Maureen Mguni (left) and Arlene Weekes

Published by Professional Social Work magazine, 27 March, 2023

Child Q (2020)

A 15-year-old girl of Caribbean descent, Child Q, was strip-searched in school by police while on her menstrual cycle, having been wrongly suspected of being in possession of cannabis at her north London school. The responsible person was the headteacher and other teachers.

Ashford child (2023)

A 15-year-old girl of Caribbean descent was viciously attacked and assaulted outside her school by other girls from her school in what was described as a continuation of an in-school squabble. The headteacher was the responsible adult. Parents and passers-by were the onlookers.

What gets in the way of safeguarding Black children?

American activist Moya Bailey (2008) describes ‘misogynoir’ as the unique combination of misogyny and anti-Black racism experienced by Black women because of the interlinking oppression, of gender and race. This expands upon Professor Kimberlé Crenshaw’s 1989 Intersectionality model and how Black women face intersectional discrimination based on gender and race.

As noted by Jahnine Davis – a leading UK specialist in safeguarding Black children, adultification may lead to professionals’ turning a blind eye to their responsibility in safeguarding Black girls. This ‘blind eye’ has its roots in the perception that Black girls and women are characteristically strong and resilient, which can also impact on perceptions of coping mechanisms, impacting on how much support is provided in comparison to other children and young people.

Claudia Bernard and Anna Gupta, in their 2008 paper Black African Children and the Child Protection System, state that there is a challenge to professionals in assessing and decision-making when working with African families due to a model of cultural deficit, based on racism and eurocentrism. The police acted without any fear of the racist implications of what they were doing in the case of Child Q. Likewise, the failure of the teachers to act quickly during the attack on the 15-year-old beaten by the white girls outside her school arguably also shows an indifference to their inaction being seen as racist. In both cases there is little, or no attention being paid to “Safeguarding is everyone’s business”, a core message in the Working Together to Safeguard Children (2018) guidance.

In the 1980s and 1990s, there was no such thing as formalised safeguarding. However, when we reflect, we have a clear sense that our schools’ walls were our protection. We have no recollection of police officers entering to chastise or police us. All fights were quickly dealt with by teachers and the fighters and pupil onlookers were dealt with promptly at school. At the time there was a general expectation by society that children were safe in school. Arguably, it might be because there was less scrutiny and therefore less exposure to the inner workings in schools. Currently, Black girls in school do not appear to be safeguarded, as in the case with the girls cited above and underlined this week by shocking statistics showing Black children are 11 times more likely to be put through the unacceptable practice of being strip-searched by the police than their white counterparts.

Perhaps, if schools are failing to protect Black children, it may lead to members of the public using social media to capture and expose such injustices as was the case with George Floyd, when a 17-year-old videoed, him being brutally murdered by police. This arguably was replicated in the case of the Surrey child, whose brutal attack was recorded, and led to MPs calling for an inquiry into the incident. Although with Child Q, media exposure was after the event, there were equivalent calls for protection of and justice for Black children. All these calls were for the eradication of institutional and structural racism that fails to safeguard.

We have equally, moved from a place of ignorance and living side-by-side with people of different cultures to a notion of cultural tolerance – the latter being an unhelpful term that means we don’t like the ‘other’ but we just put up with them.

This is at the expense of any real desire to get to know and understand members of groups we don’t belong to. Building on a previous study, Weekes (2021), emphasised that individuals needed to be supported, educated, and empowered to be consciously aware of their inherent personal and professional biases, so that they can be effective in executing their role and function.

What is needed is cultural humility – a desire to understand the ‘other’, through listening and sharing one with another - rather than cultural competence, which emphasises the acquiring of knowledge, by the ‘majority’ about the ‘other’.

Suggestions for improving practice

How can social workers work with schools and other agencies to challenge and hold each other accountable for ensuring that everyone is promoting and safeguarding African and Black Caribbean children?

It has become conventional to blame institutions for this. Why? Because it allows individuals to abdicate responsibility for their own actions, and instead project this responsibility onto intangible ‘entities’. But blaming institutions does not help. Institutions themselves consist of individuals.

According to most scholars, over a period of decades institutional racism and ‘unconscious bias’ are cited as factors that get in the way of safeguarding Black children. While there is undeniably some legitimacy in this argument, such responses do little to improve the situation.

In her recently published paper, Jo Trevenna, an educational leader, investigates the reluctance by schools in England to investigate the “intersectional discrimination” of Black pupils and the impact that this has on them. She argues that an intersectional approach could enable the formulation of more help for concerned pupils and warns about the dangers of treating all pupils as singular.

There is, of course, no overnight fix. But there are actions that can be taken as first steps in a long-term remedy. One of these actions, and probably the most effective, is to encourage and enable white people, from doctors, shop owners to police and teachers, to be aware of their biases towards Black African and Caribbean people in terms of gender, race, and ethnicity. Institutional and systemic abuses, such as racial profiling and labelling, should become a thing of the past.

Another action is to encourage a working application of contextual safeguarding – namely to understand and respond to the experiences of young Black African and Caribbean people that the ‘significant harm’ to them goes beyond their families and impacts on the public/social context, which also needs safeguarding.

Date published
27 March 2023

Join us for amazing benefits

Become a member

Have a question?

Contact us

BASW: By your side, every step of the way

British Association of Social Workers is a company limited by guarantee, registered in England. 

Company number: 00982041

Wellesley House, 37 Waterloo Street, 
Birmingham, B2 5PP
+44 (0) 121 622 3911

Contact us

Follow us

Copyright ©2023 British Association of Social Workers | Site by Agile Collective | Privacy Policy

  • About social work
    • What is social work?
      • What social workers do
      • People with lived experience
      • Regulators & professional registration
      • World Social Work Day
    • Topics in social work
    • Professional Social Work (PSW) Magazine
      • Digital editions
      • Guidance for contributors
      • PSW articles
      • Advertising
  • Careers
    • Become a social worker
    • Returning to social work
    • For employers
    • Specialisms
    • Career stages
      • Self-Employed Social Workers
        • Your tax affairs working through umbrella service companies
      • Agency and locum social work
    • Jobs board
    • Work for BASW
      • BASW Council vacancies
      • Finance & Organisational Development Committee members
  • About BASW
    • Campaigning and influencing
      • Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Social Work
      • BASW in Westminster
      • General Election 2024
      • Relationship-based practice
      • Social Work Stands Against Poverty
      • This Week in Westminster | Blog Series
      • UK Covid Inquiry
      • Professional working conditions
      • Housing & Homelessness
    • Governance
      • BASW AGM and general meetings
        • 2025 Annual General Meeting (AGM)
        • BASW GM 2025
        • Previous BASW AGMs
      • BASW Council
        • BASW Council biographies
        • BASW Council voting 2025
        • Vacancies on Council and committees 2025
      • Staff
      • Committees
      • BASW and SWU
      • Our history
      • 50 years
      • Special interest, thematic groups and experts
      • Nations
    • Social work around the UK
      • BASW Cymru
        • BASW Cymru Annual Conference 2024
        • Campaigns
      • BASW England
        • Campaigns
          • Homes Not Hospitals
          • Social Work in Disasters
          • 80-20 campaign
          • Review of Children’s Social Care
        • Meet the Team
          • BASW England Welcome Events
        • Our Services
          • Mentoring Service | BASW England
        • Social Work England
      • BASW Northern Ireland
        • About Us
        • Consultation responses
        • Find out about the BASW NI National Standing Committee
        • Political engagement
        • BASW NI & IASW's associate membership
        • BASW NI and Queen’s University Belfast launch affiliate membership
      • SASW (BASW in Scotland)
        • About Us
        • Mental Health Officer's Conference 2025
        • Our Work
          • Cross-Party Group on Social Work (Scotland)
          • Social Work Policy Panel
          • Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion
          • Supporting refugees
          • Campaigns
        • Coalitions & Partnerships
        • Get Involved
    • Awards
      • Amazing Social Workers
        • Amazing Social Workers profiles: Week 1
        • Amazing Social Workers profiles: Week 2
        • Amazing Social Workers profiles: Week 3
        • Amazing Social Workers profiles: Week 4
        • Amazing Social Workers profiles: Week 5
      • The BASW Social Work Journalism Awards
    • Social work conferences UK
      • BASW UK Student Conference 2025
      • Social work conference programme
      • The UK Social Work Conference 2025
        • Tickets and booking
        • Programme
        • Online programme
        • Speakers
        • BASW UK conference poster exhibition
        • Exhibitors
        • Venue and travel
        • Programme
    • International Work
      • Israel and Palestine/Gaza conflict | BASW/SWU Information Hub
      • IFSW and other international social work organisations
      • Influencing social work policy in the Commonwealth
      • Invasion of Ukraine | BASW Information Hub
    • Feedback, suggestions & complaints
  • Training & CPD
    • Professional Development
      • General Taught Skills Programme
      • Student Learning
      • Newly Qualified Social Worker Programme
      • Practice Educator & Assessor Programme
      • Stepping Stones Programme
      • Expert Insight Series
      • Social Work in Disasters online training
        • Module 1: Introduction to Social Work in Disasters (Online training)
        • Module 2: Law, Policy and Best Practice (Social Work In Disasters Training)
        • Module 3: Person-centred and research informed practice within a multi-agency context (Social Work in Disasters Online Training)
        • Module 4: Responding, using theory and self-care (Social Work in Disasters Online Training)
      • Overseas Qualified Social Worker (OQSW) Programme
    • Professional Capabilities Framework
      • About the PCF
      • Point of entry to training
      • Readiness for practice
      • End of first placement
      • End of last placement
      • Newly qualified social worker (ASYE level)
      • Social worker
      • Experienced social worker
      • Advanced social worker
      • Strategic social worker
    • Let's Talk Social Work Podcast
  • Policy & Practice
    • Resources
    • National policies
    • Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion
    • Working with...
      • Older people
        • Learning resources
        • Useful resources to support social work capabilities with older people
      • Autistic people
        • An introduction to the Capability Statement
        • Capabilities Statement and CPD Pathway: Resources
          • Autistic adults toolkit
            • Autistic adults toolkit introduction
            • Feedback tool
            • Induction tool
            • Introduction to video: Sylvia Stanway - Autistic not broken
            • References
            • Reflective tool
            • The role of the social worker with autistic adults
            • Top tips
          • Organisational self-assessment tool
          • Post-qualifying training programmes
        • The Capabilities Statement for Social Work with Autistic Adults
      • People with learning disabilities
        • Introduction
        • Capabilities Statement and CPD Pathway: Resources
          • People with learning disabilities toolkit
            • People with learning disabilities toolkit introduction
            • Information sheet
            • Top tips
            • Induction tool
            • Reflective tool
            • References
            • Hair tool
          • Organisational self-assessment tool
          • Post-qualifying training programmes
        • The Capabilities for Social Work with Adults who have Learning Disability
    • Research and knowledge
      • Research journals
      • BASW bookshop
    • Standards
      • Code of Ethics
        • BASW Code of Ethics: Launch of 2021 refreshed version webinar
      • Practice Educator Professional Standards (PEPS)
      • Quality Assurance in Practice Learning (QAPL)
  • Support
    • Advice & representation
    • Insurance Cover
    • Social Workers Union (SWU)
    • Social Work Professional Support Service (SWPSS)
      • Become a volunteer coach (SWPSS)
    • Independent social workers
      • Independent member benefits
      • BASW Independents Toolkit
        • Section 1: Foundations for Independent Social Work
        • Section 2: Doing Independent Social Work
        • Section 3: Running your business
        • Section 4: Decisions and transitions
      • BASW Independents directory
      • Independents digital toolkit
      • Social Work Employment Services (SWES)
    • Student Hub
      • BASW Student Ambassador Scheme
    • Financial support
      • International Development Fund (IDF)
    • Groups and networks
      • Special interest groups
        • Alcohol and other drugs Special Interest Group
        • BASW Neurodivergent Social Workers Special Interest Group (NSW SIG)
        • Family Group Conferencing (FGC)
        • Project Group on Assisted Reproduction (PROGAR)
        • The Diaspora special interest group
      • Special Interest Group on Social Work & Ageing
      • Independents local networks
      • Local branches (England)
      • Groups and forums (Scotland)
      • Thematic groups (England)
        • Black & Ethnic Minority Professionals Symposium (BPS)
        • Children & Families Group
          • Children & Families Resources Library
          • Disabled Children's Sub-group
        • Criminal Justice Group
        • Emergency Duty Team Group
        • Mental Health Group
        • Professional Capabilities and Development Group
        • Social Work with Adults Group
        • Student & Newly Qualified Group
        • Social Workers in Health Group
      • Communities of Practice (Northern Ireland)
      • Networks (Wales)
    • Membership renewals
    • How to contact us
  • Why join BASW
    • Benefits of joining BASW
      • The BASW UK University Social Work Education Provider Affiliation Scheme
    • Membership Categories
      • Student member
      • Working (qualified less than 5 years) Membership
      • Working (qualified more than 5 years) Membership
      • Independent membership
      • Newly qualified social worker
      • Retired membership
      • Unemployed/unpaid membership
    • Membership FAQs
    • Membership renewals
    • Membership fees
  • Events
  • Media Centre
    • BASW in the media
    • BASW News and blogs